THE GREAT ENIGMATIC COMPROMISE AT THE WTC SITE January 19
Since the destruction of the World Trade Center in the attacks of September 11, 2001, here in New York City we have rebuilt two stadiums for our local baseball teams, Citi Field for the New York Mets and a new Yankee Stadium, added a staircase of questionable import in Times Square and rebuilt The Highline. During this same time, many urban gentrification projects have been launched and taken to completion all over this city, the Twin Towers II plan has been virtually ignored by higher powers. Some local leaders even floated the idea of a New York Jets Stadium on the west side of Manhattan. Ironically enough, even The Time Warner Center in Columbus Circle, which was the first major building to be completed in Manhattan after the September 11, 2001 attacks, although it was already under construction in 2001, bears an uncanny resemblance to the fallen Twin Towers. If nothing else it serves as a continuing reminder of the hole in New York’s skyline, the proverbial soul of our beloved metropolis or as it has been called the “Ground Zero of National Paralysis.” Yet, here we are 8 1/2 years later and every time I walk or drive by Battery Park City, it looks nearly the same as it did when I lived there 7-8 years ago—-a construction site. This breaks my heart almost as much as the tragedy which occurred there on September 11, 2001.
Monument to Cowardice?
While persuasive arguments exist to modernize and remake the downtown financial district to suit the needs of a city looking forward to the next century rather than those of the prior one, the symbolism of making the skyline less of what it once was is not lost on many citizens of America and the World. Did we not repair the Pentagon to its original form, prior to the attacks? It is also not lost on me that their may be insufficient corporate demand to fill the World Trade Center were it to be re-built much in the same way again. Nevertheless, the tragedy has provided New York City with an opportunity to re-craft downtown for the next century. The dilemma of how far we should go in our dreams to rebuild bigger, better and stronger is only eclipsed by how little rebuilding we have done since 9/11 and how compromised is the existing plan of Studio Daniel Libeskind and his high profile collaborators, relative to the passion of architect Minoru Yamasaki which inspired their construction in the first place. Rebuilding efforts have been repeatedly stalled after legal fights with insurers, clashes over design and security and a failure to attract tenants. Under existing plans a glass skyscraper, formerly known as the “Freedom Tower” (which was appropriately labeled by journalist Nicole Gelinas as “a half-hollowed monument to cowardice”) but renamed One World Trade Center last year, will be the tallest building in the United States, at the symbolic height of 1776 feet, and the centerpiece of the new World Trade Center site. The site will also include a National September 11 Memorial and Museum. Work on the formerly named Freedom Tower officially began in late 2006 and is now scheduled to be completed sometime in 2013.
Rebuilding Ground Zero
This past week we learned that Oscar winning film director Steven Spielberg will make a TV documentary on the rebuilding of New York’s World Trade Center. The Science Channel reported that Spielberg would executive produce the six-part documentary series “Rebuilding Ground Zero”, due to be shown in 2011. Along with Project Rebirth this proves once again that so many projects can be taken to completion, even movies about the rebirth before an actual rebirth.
Twin Towers Alliance
The Twin Towers Alliance remains the conscience of a city, a country and the silent majority of American Citizens who do not embrace the project underway at the site of the former World Trade Center, but who individually lack a voice or have moved on to issues that they can affect in their own lives, having accepted almost that their leaders are no longer listening to them. This is not a liberal or conservative issue, or even a Democratic or Republican one, or for that matter even an American one, there is a Worldwide Coalition to Rebuild the Twin Towers. You can even join their Facebook page, contact the media or become part of the One Million Strong for new Twin Towers. According to the founders of the Twin Towers Alliance, the current plan does not pass the smell test:
It certainly is curious that men like Mr. Bloomberg and Mr. Silverstein, who know that terrorist targets in Israel are always quickly rehabilitated back to their pre-target state — as the best relief for the victims and the best demoralizer for the victimizers — would work to deprive their country of the same relief. Why the double standard? Why are they going along with towers and a memorial that do just the opposite, making the physical proof of the attacks permanent and giving our enemies the most gigantic terrorist trophy the world has ever seen? ? It doesn’t compute — it boggles the mind. Why would they be so hostile to the natural desire of their own countrymen for that same simple standard, knowing what an effective deterrent it is in Israel against the same enemy? Especially when the possibility of restoring the skyline to its world-famous profile is so much more popular, economical, buildable, and ultimately rewarding for all concerned? Why would they seek to marginalize and defame those who object? Whose side are they on anyway?
While I mostly find myself in agreement with much of what the Twin Towers Alliance position, where I take exception is that I think Mike Bloomberg and his team have done a rather remarkable job to advance the interests of New York City in some of the most trying times. This is especially true when you consider the fundamental shift in the global economy and the modern economic reality in America, the challenge or threat to American supremacy. Consider further the challenges posed by a shrinking financial sector in lower Manhattan, including soaring vacancy rates, which very much impact the kind of facilities which make sense to build downtown at this stage of New York history. In short, it is hard not to appreciate the passion and intent of the folks at the Twin Towers Alliance while being sympathetic to the economic and political realities being dealt with by our business and political leaders. Hesitance and caution are a natural reaction, but not necessarily the right reaction.
A Modern Utopia: Once the Vision of Andrew Cuomo
The will of the people may call for new Twin Towers. Demand in the business community for commercial space of that magnitude may not currently exist. On the other hand, perhaps the vacancy rate exists downtown because the alternatives that exist for the type of Manhattan we are attempting to craft do not exist or are not modern enough to attract the kind of tenants that would consider relocating to Lower Manhattan. And I am not just talking about creating just more square footage at a cheaper price which would create a downtown vs. midtown chess game between a few of the largest landowners in the city. What I am instead talking about is a modern if not futuristic Urban Enterprise Zone that is designed to lure business from other parts of the country and the world because The World Trade Center is not just a name but in essence an “Olympic Village of Commerce” where the best and brightest must come to be in proximity of the greatest minds in Capitalism in the free world. Simply put, there has always been a certain romance with Downtown (consider the opening credits for the movie Wall Street) and that romance must be recreated to lure new generations back. If you don’t get it, then you probably think that the World Trade Center was just a couple of skyscrapers.
New Yorkers should be looking for and turning to someone with the creativity of Andrew Cuomo, the current Attorney General, who was a gubernatorial candidate back in 2002 who saw the opportunity to build a new utopia rather than just a few pleasant high rises, a memorial or a cemetery. According to the Gotham Gazette:
Although Andrew Cuomo ultimately dropped out of the race, his rebuilding plans were some of the most creative of any of the major candidates. He saw the rebuilt downtown area as a sort of high-tech capitalist utopia: New York City cultural landmarks, a relocated World Bank, an integrated transportation system, a developed waterfront with a harbor economy, and a newly commissioned World Institute of Health, doing valuable research while also creating a biotechnology economy.
If the corporate demand does not exist for every square foot of space in the Twin Towers right now, perhaps as a forward thinking Urban Enterprise Zone we can remake New York City for the 21st Century and beyond. In so doing we must be prepared to look at things not in such a microeconomic manner in terms of what may be filled up next week, next month or even next year. The question is not whether New York City can afford to do this and make the investment now but whether New York City can afford to cede ground to other centers of trade and commerce, such as Kuala Lampur in Malaysia (see the Petronas Towers), Dubai or Hong Kong. If we do not then the name World Trade Center will end up signifying not just a dream unfulfilled but a reality we were unwilling to invest in its creation and thus ultimately meaningless. Make no mistake that a series of high rises and monument to the deceased will only serve to remind that this is no longer The World Trade Center, but that it once was and it, New York and America will RIP.
EPILOGUE: It should be noted that the folks at Twin Towers Alliance are absolutely correct. This blog left out a key point, that Twin Towers II calls for very much the same kind of mixed use facility, similar to one of the signature properties in midtown west at the Time Warner Center at Columbus Circle, which ironically also has Twin Towers. I find it hard to believe that there will be insufficient demand for personal or corporate homes in a truly rebuilt World Trade Center with views from the Windows at the Top of the World. And it should be noted that Twin Towers Alliance while giving Mayor Bloomberg his due for his governance during troubled times, believe that his governance will ultimately be judged as a net gain or net loss, depending on what happens in Lower Manhattan. Here we are in 2010, with the opportunity still to correct what is wrong at the World Trade Center site. During the immediate aftermath of the attacks of September 11th and all the pandemonium and political posturing and grandstanding by political leaders like then Governor George Pataki who promised a vocal minority of victims families that there would be no building on the footprints at Ground Zero and still others who lobbied for no building at all on Ground Zero, we can recognize and reflect on the folly or lack of wisdom and perspective in those promises and the power plays behind the flawed process, especially since those who attempted to control the debate had no background in urban planning and bare some responsibility for the rest of the world passing us by. The future or the fate of America and its signature metropolis should not be beholden to those promises offered in the heat of passion, political passion that is, by leaders with a compromised vision to a somewhat misguided but vocal minority, especially when no significant evidence exists that a majority of the families ever wanted or insisted that New York essentially build a cemetery downtown. This is New York City and “NOT” Iken Pataki Town. Furthermore, it is wise to consider that we do not remake our entire society based upon the voices of a few, with all due respect, but rather our society shall advance forward to the benefit the majority of our citizens and our culture as a whole by cool, calm and strategic reflection about what is necessary to advance us as a people. Will we be happy when for years folks come to visit the World Trade Center as a “Disneyland of Death” rather than for it being the center of commerce, commercial enterprise and capitalism itself? It’s really a rather simple question.
ML Donovan Jan 19
We got a “Twin Towers II” Google Alert directing us to this page. Thank you for weaving together a remarkable piece.
Aside from the arguments you advance is one you don’t mention: “Twin Towers II” would be a mixed-use facility (as is the Time Warner Center), which would further enhance the vibrancy of the project.
I am happy to give the devil his due. Mayor Bloomberg has done some very good things — but only time will tell whether or not his leadership will be a net gain or loss for this most fabulous of cities.
Canada Goose Jackets Feb 11
Welcome to our canada goose jackets.net, here meeting for the demand of people for winter goose down jackets canada, we do our best to offer the series of canada goose parka for your need. There are Chilliwack parka canada goose, canada goose Expedition, Snow Mantra parka canada goose; at the same time, Canada Goose online store supplys Canada goose women as follows: CANADA GOOSE TRILLIUM PARKA, Canada Goose Solaris Parka black, red, white, brown etc, women’s canada goose jackets reviews.
Juicy Couture Outlet Aug 30
Content of the article you write so well
Ugg Boots Clearance Sep 13
i find your website are splendid..i learn a lot of things from ur website,, thanks,,very
Ugg Boots Clearance Sep 13
i like this website,good website,,i can get a lot of things from ur website,thanks
Discount Ugg Boots Sep 13
wo,,,i find your website are unique,,i like your website good website ,i will come again
Cheap Ugg Boots Sep 13
i like your website very much thanks,,,i get some useful imformation from your website,thanks
north face outlet Sep 28
Somewhere throughout the sentences you were able to make me a believer but only for a short while.
UGGs Outlet Oct 7
In the winter, especially the chill winter, to have a pair of warm UGGs Outlet boots?is a big bliss, while UGG Outlet to have a pair of UGG Sale boots is considered to be a gift from God. UGG make you a very warm throughout the winter!
tiffany co outlet Nov 1
it’s called burden-bearing. Pitifully, most
SF Nov 1
I would like to thank you for the time you have made in composing this article. I am hoping the same top-grade blogpost from you in the upcoming as well. In fact your creative writing skill has inspired me to start my own blog now. Truly the blogging is spreading its wings rapidly. Your write up is a fine example of it.
????
??sf
Cheap NFL Jerseys
uggs Nov 3
Liesl Garner works at ugg boots on sale , an authorized online retailer for UGG Australia Boots.The hottest new boot this fall is the ugg boots for sale , available in kids, toddlers and mom sizes!The Kid’s Retro Cargo is also available in sizes for women and children.Please protect yourself from fraudulent online sellers by educating yourself about Fake-UGGs!
Tiffany and co outlet Nov 7
Thank you for ur information,I really like it
Lebron Shoes Nov 7
it takes my breath away!! All the beautiful details, coloring and that ribbon are just wonderful!!
Lebron Shoes Nov 7
Thank you for making such a nice website.
ugg boots uk Nov 10
The post which with profound cultural leavel and rich social experience,it can be the classics of the irony,and we must admit that,this is just the degree where we are pursuing.!
ugg boots Nov 13
Howdy! Very good subject matter, your internet site fails to display screen on FF4 toy with. Does indeed any equipment prohibit the IP address? Appreciate it.
Dr.Dre Beats In-Ear Nov 17
This will give you a test to discover if people are appreciating your work.Dr.Dre Beats Solo HD Having people
listen and work on your beats also Justbeats Headphonesgives you experience and exposure.Want to produce high quality music and sound beats at home? Beat Maker Software is the ultimate way.
moncler Nov 20
These simple color and comfortable wearing Moncler Jackets and Moncler vest will never out of fashion.Moncler Created in 1952 in Grenoble, France by Rene Ramillon, the brand name of Moncler is adapted from a small village named Monastier de Clermont near Grenoble. Over the years Moncler has grown significantly as a premium clothing brand that offers stylish and comfortable garments for men and women. it is no longer just for sportsmen but has been well-known and loved by more and more ordinary people. Everyone likes to have a warm
Moncler Jackets, wearing which will not looks bloated and can move with ease.If you are interested in this kind of product and put an order to our site, you could save as much as 70%. We promise you that we could offer you the lowest prize but with the high quality clothes in all Moncler designs.
The brand name of Moncler came from the abbreviation of Monestier de Clermon. It is a brand specialized in the production of outdoor sports equipments. As the secure and trusted Mincler materials are gradually recognized by the world, Moncler Down Jackets can be the one that meets your requirements, more than that, it can show your good figures as well as your unique styles when wearing Moncler Down Jacket. They help you to drive away the cold and bring you a good mood, and they are just exactly what you are looking for. Shopping Moncler Jacket on moncler online shop and Moncler Jackets uk online shop where different designers and different styles jackets are widely collected And I hope we could establish relationship in a long term on the basic.
ugg bailey button boots Nov 21
Producing using of the circumstance for UGG Classic ” booties “, you certainly prefer the label. That labeled around the back again as just stated signifies it could possibly be the specific deal. One can find so severely many imposters these days, you do not would like to acquire stuck producing using of the fake and finally end up the patsy. Article source: Cheap UGGs, UGG outlet, ugg bailey button sale.
cheap ugg boots Nov 23
Concurrently, consider the width from the stockings you want to wear with the individual’s ugg classic tall 5815 boots, thus in terms of not have access to an excellent fitted problem after.Reliability: You attempt to make sure to consider authentic Australian ugg bailey button 5803 boots In . shoes " from respected vendors.
beatsbydre-onlineshop Nov 23
GIVE somewhat MOREGiving Energy. Making it possible for ResilienceHave you thought such as giving up due to the fact whatever you do appears to visit nothing?Give a a bit more.Giving just a little much more can be all beats by dr dre studio takes in order to launch to be able to actual successful. Farm pets could win simply "by a nostril,Inches knowning that nasal area is it will require to make history. So it is with as much as possible worth cheap beats by dr dre . Essentially the most effective people are usually absolutely no better compared to much less or perhaps defeated, however they are frequently individuals are willing to question yet another query, grab once more. The top those who win usually are not always those that didn’t dropped as well as recently been disappointed.
indagarage Nov 24
I love Silverstone and the facilities have certainly improved – even the toilets are acceptable
louboutin sale Dec 7
louboutin sale
ralph lauren polo Dec 7
ralph lauren polo
Custom Logo Design Dec 9
Very good post. i took inspiration for logo.
north face outlet Dec 12
Have you ever walked past a designer shop, looked in the window display the north face outlet and felt as though a bag was calling you by name? Or maybe you happen to see it in a catalogue? cheap oakleys That’s beautiful things and tell yourself apart. Ok, so now to make the tough cheap oakley sunglasses decision on why you should spend $1000 or more (can be several hundred thousands) on. Thank you for posting .please do more good article.the north face outlet it’s so cool .i like it very much.
beats by dre Dec 15
According to “the central club” 12 days of reports, beats by dre a us study shows, diamond star theory do exist. These huge planet volume is the earth’s several times as large as, by precious diamond is composed.
But new research shows that these “diamond star” if there really is our galaxy, is in 73 to 250 light years outside, and may be biological cannot survive place.
According to the report, the study leader the Ohio State University (Ohio State University) earth academy of sciences associate professor palmer Nero (Wendy Panero) issued a statement said: “we think diamond star must be very cold and dark place.”
To those who want to get rich in outer space, have a let them more sad news, namely diamond in fact buried in the planet’s surface graphite depths.
And palmer Nero Wolfe doctoral research together, Berne (CaymanUnterborn) said, diamonds can be located in 150 miles (kilometers) below the surface. beats by dre australia Speak more clearly on the earth, cut out the deepest pothole for about 12 kilometers. Set of words, the Berne words: “to use very powerful instrument, can drill so deep place.”
The last week in San Francisco, Berne American Geophysical Union autumn Meeting (American Geophysical Union Fall Meeting) published the study results.
Palmer Nero says, the diamond star in the internal structure of the earth with like, dr dre Cuffie there are many layers. However, most of the earth’s core is iron, and have a lot of mantle minerals containing silicon, and the interior of the main is diamond planet by carbon atoms.
Ohio university says, the earth’s temperature high internal can generate geothermal, beats by dre uk let our planet suitable for living.
However, diamond heat transfer speed, carbon super the interior of the earth soon frozen, it says it will not have geothermal heat, no plate tectonic, finally also does not have the magnetic field or the atmosphere.
supra high tops Jan 8
Just to look it, thanks for sharing, hoping to see more content from u soon.Your faithful friends.
supra skytop Jan 8
This is the best blog, I like it very much, and I believe that many more people will get help from here.thanks again.
Canada Goose Jan 9
The stylish parka jacket is built from synthetic sources and zips along theCanada Goose vesteentrance for closure. Down-filled parkas are presently the norm jackets, but artificial fills can also be amazingly heat and appreciably added animal pleasant for your requirements vegans living. Fundamentally, parka jacket type has remained comparable collectively combined with the exception of front zip closure, collectively employing the entry to breathable, fast-wicking water-proof outer components.Canada Goose is usually a primary provider of Canada Goose Jackets and CanadaCanada Goose Goose Parka supplied globally on your winter coats and outwear industries. it is an extremely common Model of out of doors gears inside of the whole world. Although there a variety of detrimental outcomes for that fakes, its model and premium quality are by and large goods and fulfilling, since it is certainly value buying. The fashionable parka jacket has synthetic resources and zips along the entrance for closure. Down-filled parkas are presently the norm, but
Canada Goose Sale artificial fills may be unbelievably heat and considerably added animal friendly for your requirements personally vegans out there. Basically, parka jacket model has remained the comparable collectively in addition to the exception of front zip closure, collectively using the admission to breathable, fast-wicking water-proof outer elements.To start with look, prospects are usually surprised in which the Chilliwack a lot pricey comparedCanada Goose Mens Parka towards the Gotham (for costs see Related Products on your bottom on your page). A huge difference in amount could very well be partly explained since Canada Goose is stated in Canada and then the North Facial area is based in China. I reckon that is a crucial point the way it Canada goose jackets rare that makers make their outdoor clothing in Canada, together with a great achievement examining the option of labor throughout our nation. All the same, we must always find the very simple fact that creates jackets around the a tremendous amount lower Canada Goose scale than the North Encounter, to whom it will probably be out of the question to offer like a significant quantity only in Usa factories.For males who dash grease parka considerably additional formal environments,Canada Goose Chilliwack a denim jacket granted that
Canada Goose mens Citadel your shirt and slacks is definitely a quick viewpoint to have down after to start dating ? in the workplace. No matter what prior to the context, some form of nicely wearied blue casing sits in uncomplicated point on pretty males, regardless age. For women, denim is remarkably much more of the Canada goose actualize merchandise. Designers desire denim instead of consistently recreate and restyle both jackets and jeans on your shifting seasons. down jackets concentrate additional whilst in the preference on the jackets, that allow so
womens Solaris Parka that it is a lot more well-known. It’s actually acknowledged to every that Canada Goose is a top-level brand within the down jacket style earth. It can be explained that Canada Goose are prevailing among several superstars, nearly every single superstar in Hollywood owns 1 down jacket .Quite a few celebrities could also be Canada Goose down jackets. Canadas chilly cold weather, Canada Goose Jacket has grew that should be significantly more crucial, specially people dwelling in cold climates. Clothes to your shows age, you will be fundamentally around the domestic coming of much of
Canada Goose Mens Chateau Parka the vital requirements. The Canada Goose down parkas own an exterior manufactured to withstand the cold and wind jackets.http://www.canada-goose-factory.com
Monster Beats Jan 14
The weather is becoming hotter and hotter, and people’s emotion also become more and more irritable for the hot weather. They can be easier to quarrel with other people for some small things, for example, you are on the bus to go to work, and as we all know that the bus must be very crowded in the rush hour and all people hurry to work so it can be very more prone to have dispute with other people. It can be significant to
SOLO High Performance On-Ear Headphones(White) have a method to aid them calm down their emotion and I know listening to the music may be a great way to assist you to calm down your feeling so you need a great pair of headphones to listen to the music. As we all know, Monster Beats Headphones have a fantastic reputation in this field. With Monster Beats Headphones you possibly can get pleasure from the great wonderful morning and you’ll be able to have a good emotion with delightful music and begin the new day!
Monster Beats As far as I’m concerned, music is the greatest invention in the human development. It can be a good way to express our emotion and help us to adjust our bad mood, a pair of good headphones can be the most important part for you to listen to the music because you can have the original music which is created by the composers. Monster Beats can be the your best choice if you want to listen to the excellent music because Monster Beats can offer you the top tone quality which can give you the really wonderful experience when you listen to the music. As we all know that, some headphones in poor quality will break the delightful music which the composer
Beats by Dr.Dre Justbeats produce so we can get the answer that how crucial that a superb pair of headphone to have the music. Monster Beats can have the leading tone high quality if you get pleasure from the music and you may obtain it is a good strategy to give your self a superb mood for those who are inside the bad mood. Monster Beats Headphone can give you one of the most fantastic listening experience and give you probably the most top tone high quality. Do you ever believe you could get pleasure from the soft music inside the morning with excellent weather and you’ll be able to give your self an excellent mood to star a day, as we know that when you have a superb emotion within the morning you can have sustained the superior emotion all day long. Monster Beats Headphones can provide you with an opportunity to get pleasure from the music from the morning and once you are in a poor mood the soft music aid you calm down the worried emotion. I think you may fall in love with it when you have a chance to encounter Monster Beats Headphones. Free shipping, leading good quality and quick delivery you possibly can use much less funds to purchase the leading excellent headphone which you are searching for. About author: So music lovers, sit back and relax, and take pleasure in the sound that comes from the advanced engineering, the care, as well
Beats by Dr.Dre Tour as the passion that we put into Turbines. Welcome to our monster beats outlet If you listen to your favorite music with justin bieber beats, I’ll promise that it is going to sound as when you had been listening to it for the very first time once again. Do not hesitate, justbeats solo headphones may be your best Cheap Monster Beats selection!
Christian Louboutin Jan 18
Very good written article. It will be helpful to anyone who uses it, including yours truly. Keep up the good work – for sure i will check out more posts. http://www.louboutinshoes2u.com